🔗 Share this article

The Duke of York's public image has suffered a further major damage with new newspaper disclosures exposing an email that suggests he continued ties with disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein more extensively than he had previously claimed.

These claims are extremely damaging for the Duke of York.

The revealed email casts direct suspicion on his account of events presented during his television interview, where he claimed he had cut ties with Epstein after meeting him in New York in December 2010, when the duo were pictured together.

The familiar tone of the email Andrew is alleged to have sent - "We are in this together" - also weakens endeavors to argue they were never familiar.

Negative publicity hasn't exactly been uncommon to the Duke of York.

The email revealed by newspapers is alleged to be from February 2011, and previously this year a further set of emails from that identical time emerged, also indicating that Andrew's association with Epstein had endured months later than he had stated, which prompted a equivalent round of scathing headlines.

What Consequences Could Follow?

Each scandal is succeeded by requests for Prince Andrew to face some kind of royal sanction. So what leverage can the King and the Royal Family effectively use? How could they separate themselves?

The next major family gathering for the royals is Christmas in Sandringham. And it seems improbable that Prince Andrew and his former spouse Sarah Ferguson will be invited. He'll be marginalized. And don't anticipate to see him in the background in the King's Christmas message; any sightings will have been edited out.

The only King that Andrew is expected to see will be if Good King Wenceslas comes up on the Christmas carol playlist.

Andrew missed last year's customary royal Christmas because of an reported Chinese spy scandal, and that omission seems probable to extend for a further year. It won't have assisted that Sarah Ferguson has been in her own Epstein email scandal - with multiple of her UK charities ending ties with her.

Accommodation and Financial Issues

There have been ongoing calls for Prince Andrew to be ousted from Royal Lodge, his extensive mansion in Windsor. But Andrew has his own independent lease with the Crown Estate that extends until 2078. Much of the payments of transferring there were front-loaded when he took on the property in 2003, and there's limited obvious incentive for Andrew to vacate now.

If Andrew can afford to pay his bills at Royal Lodge, then it's not obvious how he can be evicted.

Royal insiders say that the King has tried many methods to implement pressure, like cutting off Andrew's allowance last year.

But Prince Andrew seems to have cultivated his own independent sources of finance since withdrawing from public life, including economic connections with China, the Gulf States, and a newly limited project with a Dutch start-up company. He has demonstrated financially resilient, despite what must be significant outlays in paying for his own security.

Titles and Official Roles

There have been requests to remove Andrew of his honors, such as the Duke of York. That suggestion has considerable public support, with a YouGov poll over the summer indicating that 67% of people supported removing his remaining titles.

It would require the action of Parliament, but there is a legal process. It was employed during the First World War to discipline aristocrats who had UK titles but were fighting in the German army.

So it's not unfeasible that such a meaningful move might be pursued if the ongoing of scandal became too much to overlook.

Andrew has continued a Knight of the Garter, a prestigious honorary award, which in theory could be withdrawn. Although at now he doesn't take part in the yearly public ceremony in Windsor and is limited to the private parts of the regular ceremony.

There was once an elaborate process for excluding someone from being a member of the Order of the Garter, known as "degradation". But that hasn't been employed since the 18th Century. More lately members were simply withdrawn, such as the leaders of Britain's opponents in the First World War, Wilhelm II of Germany and Franz Joseph of Austria-Hungary.

Benito Mussolini, Robert Mugabe, and Nicolae Ceausescu all had honors removed. Although the last-mentioned, the Romanian dictator, had his Order of the Bath honor withdrawn the day before he was executed by a firing squad, so it might not have seemed his greatest worry.

Current Status

On earlier precedent, the Palace has preferred a more subtle approach to removing status. There was discomfort that Prince Andrew stayed a advisor of state, who could deputise for the King if he was out of the country or was ill. Rather than openly remove him, new counsellors were appointed in 2022 so that Prince Andrew would never have to be employed.

Prince Andrew has already forfeited his HRH title and military affiliations - and since he's no longer a "active royal" he doesn't have any formal royal obligations. It also signified that Buckingham Palace ceased being accountable for his actions.

There have been proposals that the Royal Family should go a step further and "remove" Prince Andrew from public life.

He's already not allowed to attend royal public events. Instead, his appearances are confined to confidential, family events, such as memorials. That circumstance seems probable to endure. Not least because as leader of the Church of England, the King couldn't exactly be viewed prohibiting his brother from religious services.

Ongoing Challenges

But the Palace must be concerned by these continuous waves of scandal impacting over such a direct relative to the King. It risks to overshadow their own more noble projects. And it remains unknown what might still emerge from the trawl of information regarding Epstein.

Campaigners against the monarchy say there should be a wider examination into what the Royal Family might have knowledge of about Prince Andrew's connections to Epstein.

"This is not only about family. It's not a confidential matter," says an anti-monarchy campaigner, chief executive of Republic.

The Prince Andrew's office has been approached for comment.